Designing the Spot the Future campaigns together

Content

1. Information architecture
2. Copy: Seeding the future campaign
3. Copy: Making a Living campaign
4. Copy: We, the People campaign
5. Copy: Caring for Commons campaign


1. Information architecture

We propose to roll out Spot The Future-related topics as grouped into three broad meta-topics called campaigns, as per the Edgeryders tradition. We would have three campaigns, that reflect the research interests of the Country offices; plus a more generic “Seeding the future” campaign to catch interesting things that don’t fit nicely in the mold. They are rolled out in parallel; the social media team feeds new traffic to the websites by pushing out individual units of content (posts).

Campaigns are project-wide, not country-specific, as we welcome the opportunity to compare notes across different countries.

We work together to write what we call campaign briefs: short, clear instructions to people willing to contribute on how to do so. The brief text is embedded in the body field (Full HTML) of a group node corresponding to each campaign. The brief should:

  • Be at most two-three paragraphs long (excluding resources – example).

  • Include links to resources where the participant can learn more about the issue at hand.

  • Mention specific challenges that people are encouraged to address. For example, within the Making a Living mission, we could include a poverty reduction challenge: there are people that are so poor they simply can’t afford to look beyond their next meal, so we can’t expect them to dream up and execute strategies to lift themselves to more secure condition, no matter how smart they might be. Do you know of any successful experience in addressing this challenge? What are people doing to cope? Explanations and data on challenges should be contained in resources, not the brief itself. We can also make our own resources, of course.

  • Emphasize experience for example, a brief on environmental degradation would invite participants to tell us how they, or people in their community, are fighting it while making sure they mitigate the negative impact (if any) on economic activity of doing so.

  • Contain a link (“Get started”, “Start this mission” or equivalent) that passes to Drupal the PHP code to create a new post within the Mission group (care of @matthias).

Participants respond to the campaigns authoring what we call missions. These are simply blog posts, nested under the appropriate campaign node. Since they are posts, missions are commentable. We use comments to ask questions and engage participants in conversation about their experiences related to these campaigns and their challenges. Summarizing, here is how the different pieces of this information architecture fit together:

In the conversation In the database Who writes it Translation?
Campaign Group node Team Yes
Challenge Page or wiki nested in the group Team Flexible
Mission Post nested in the group The community Normally not
Comment Comment to the posts Team and community No

2. Copy: Seeding the future

The copy for this campaign is already online and translated into Armenian and Georgian. This content will go to the Arrivals group, where STFers have more chances to mingle with their peers in the Edgeryders community.

3. Copy: Making a Living (draft version)

Throughout Europe we are seeing people with high level of qualifications unable to find work according to their expectations, and many have no choice but settle for temporary and underpaid contracts outside their domain of interest. Others are taking up internships, most often unpaid, in the hope that these will land them a paid job.

Over half of young Armenians (18-35) don’t have a job and two thirds of them have never had one. Poor working conditions and generalized mistrust create an even bigger gap since some people stop looking altogether. In Egypt, unemployment has always been a growing concern, especially for youth. In recent times there has been a sharp decline in the economy, consequently causing an increase in the unemployment rate from 8.9% (2010) to 13.4% (2013) (more).

But are jobs really the way forward for all of us? Or the only way to lead meaningful and fulfilled adult lives?

Over time a kind of consensus has emerged amongst some Edgeryders community members that we need to look for other safety nets. That governments ceased being able to fullfill that promise a long time ago. Some even suggest that the idea of a job in itself is obsolete. Several of us have found paths that defy convention, here are some examples from the community:

  • The unMonastery is a subsidized hackers’ space where innovators from all over work with a local community to solve challenges on-site, in exchange for housing and meals assured. It happens now in Matera, South Italy!

  • @rhithink got fed up with being part of the “generation without a future” and created a platform to support UK co-operatives set up by graduates who are navigating transition to work, all while de-constructing what “young and successful” means nowadays.

What about you? How are you making a living? We’re very interested to compare notes with peers in other parts of the world, young and not so young, especially in the following areas:

  1. Getting paid work: Where do you and your peers look for opportunities to work? If you’re a young graduate, do the skills you learned in school help?

  2. Self-managed careers: How are you making room for yourself as an entrepreneur or trail blazer in a field? What supports your work or service?

  3. Poverty reduction: Do you know of an innovative initiative that helps people living in poverty meet their personal needs and/or provides access to basic services? What started it and how are people coping, physically and psychologically? Tell us about it.

To participate in this conversation simply create a post and tell us about your experience. If you´are not already signed in to the Edgeryders platform you can do it here.

Why join? You will be amazed to discover you’re not alone, and your peers across the world are facing similar challenges! By sharing your story you’re making a first step to connect with a community of support. We are seeing already how giving each other advice makes us stronger and much faster at fixing the Big problems our societies are faced with. If you don’t know where to start, simply read the posts below, they’re inspiring! Looking forward to read you.

*A small number of selected stories will be published and paid for.

4. Copy: We the People (draft version)

It used to be that youth policy around participation was focused on bringing youth into the institutional forms of participation, is this still the case?

According to respondents in the Post2015 Development survey civic participation from their part means engaging in a secure and empowering environment, the ability and possibility to speak and to be heard, an agreed vision with the government of where to go and how, and being provided at least medium living standards. An honest and responsive government was perceived as a precondition for creating such an enabling environment. (source: Georgian preliminary Post2015 consultations report provided by UNDP)

In Edgeryders we are seeing how citizens – especially the younger ones – are active in creating their own initiatives and spaces that work with different kinds of procedures and practices than institutional politics. And that civic and political participation is not some activity or engagement separated from the rest of their lives: people can be involved as thoughtful consumers or boycotters; adopters of alternative currencies (sharing as opposed to buy-sell practices); users of particular digital tools (e.g. the free software movement) etc. These choices are in themselves political, yet they lie outside formalized, institutional spaces. That, too is civic participation (source).

We would like to know how you, your families, friends and acquaintances are We try to address the following challenges:

  1. Responsive government. When the government is deeply engaged in a many-to-many dialogue with the citizenry, good things happen. Decision makers have access to high-quality information about what goes on; citizens and businesses can help prevent crises by giving government officials early warning. However, many government agencies are focused on their internal process, and find it difficult to change course quickly when citizens bring new information to the table. How are you making your government (national or local) more responsive? Do you know of any initiative or project that is helping public sector agencies engage in open dialogue with citizens?

  2. Citizen-institution interaction. In many democracies, traditional forms of participation are in deep crisis. Elections turnout is decreasing, especially among younger citizens [need data to support this]. Meanwhile, committed individuals are inventing new forms of participation, from critical consumption to interrogating government data to make sense of what is going on (open data).How are you making your voice heard? Do you know of groups or initiatives that are exploring new way to be the citizen of a modern state?

  3. Others…?

To participate in this conversation simply create a post and tell us about your experience.

Why join? You will be amazed to discover you’re not alone, and your peers across the world are facing similar challenges! By sharing your story you’re making a first step to connect with a community of support. We are seeing already how giving each other advice makes us stronger and much faster at fixing the Big problems our societies are faced with. If you don’t know where to start, simply read the posts below, they’re inspiring! Looking forward to read you.

*A small number of selected stories will be published and paid for.

5. Copy: Caring for commons (draft version)

Commons are resources such as land, water, food, as well as digital assets that belong to everyone, but deteriorate through excessive use when we hit their renewability limits. What can we do to enhance them, so that they can better sustain social production and healthy social relationships? Spot the Future sets out to capture inspiring green shots and see what issues - economic, social and legal - need to be addressed if we are to build and inhabit a world of green commons.

Many of the initiatives displayed on Edgeryders are about creating new infrastructures based on commoning and sharing as creative responses to ecological, economic and political crises. They are trying anything and everything all at the same time, engaging in radical innovation and working often outside any formal spaces:

  • Let’s Do it World: a movement where masses of individuals get together to clean up waste in response to government’s failure to do so (@auli and Henri Laupmaa in Estonia)

  • Prinzessinengarten in Berlin is an outstanding example of citizen mobilization for creating an urban agriculture amounting to a whole new social infrastructure (@caroline in Berlin)

  • Building intentional communities like the Freelab in rural Poland that serves the local community by offering social and technical support and education (@petros_at_freelab).

Also at the borders of Europe and beyond we see many grassroots groups massively organizing to reclaim the green spaces that surround them: "We are the owners of this city” in Yerevan, “Saving Vake Park” in Tbilisi or cycling mobs promoting alternative lifestyles – “Tie and Wind”. These groundbreaking ways combine community spirit, peer to peer learning and economic value, while increasing resilience.

Help us discover more good doers, creative activists and projects caring for their environments! Identify an initiative to raise awareness on environmental damages in your city and tell us about it. Is there collaboration involved? What value does it bring to the community?

Why join? You will be amazed to discover you’re not alone, and your peers across the world are facing similar challenges! By sharing your story you’re making a first step to connect with a community of support. We are seeing already how giving each other advice makes us stronger and much faster at fixing the Big problems our societies are faced with. If you don’t know where to start, simply read the posts below, they’re inspiring! Looking forward to read you.

*A small number of selected stories will be published and paid for.

1 of the submission pages on the minisite “contribute an essay” page doesn’t correspond to the schedulted theme for this week “PARTICIPATION IN DECISION MAKING IN GEORGIA”. It could be replaced with this one to stay in theme:

https://edgeryders.eu/youth-education-and-employment-in-georgia

Making a living in Georgia not a highlight

The final priorities for each country are listed in the table above, the rest we can push less even though employment in Georgia could also show up as one of the topics of interest for participants - eg in a story in the Arrivals group for example…

1 Like

I completely agree as the unemployment in Georgia is problematic. Hence I have a question: why employment was excluded as one of the general topics?  http://www.myworldgeorgia.org/result.php?lang=en shows that the top 2 priorities for Georgians are good education and better job opportunities.

1 Like

Check in progress

@inga_popovaite no worries. UNDP country offices are aware of the wiki and have been warned to check it and make the changes they want to see.

1 Like

You are right

Hi Inga, that was a response regarding more specific inquiries for participants which should be consistent with the above table . They are by no means closed doors. As you can see reading the mission brief above on Making a Living, it is in no way exclusive of Georgians, on the contrary, we’re looking for stories in all three countries in all these overarching themes - you can’t really separate one or the other because they are complemetary and overlapping facets of how people live, work and participate in society. We just wanted to make sure we’re not losing focus on project deliverables :slight_smile: For the community and general engagement, literally any story is relevant, beyond themes or ontologies.

1 Like

Finished caring for commons Mission Brief

/t/spot-the-future-caring-for-commons/559

Priorities for Georgia

@inga_popovaite - great to see that you’re following post 2015 priorities in Georgia! In fact, apart from good governance, there were other priorities highlighted during consultations as well, like access to healthcare, education, employment and security at large. And I agree with @noemi already, the discussion is free to touch any of them, we narrowed it down to citien and decision-maker interraction and responsive governance as it echos the process of upcoming public administration reform in Georgia. However, I personally would be very much interested to see what the Edgeryder community might come up with in terms of education and youth employment in Georgia.

2 Likes

This looks good to me - let’s shake the trees.

I’m sat with Vahagn and Marina

a quick q: Above it suggests that we won’t translate the comments… how will we incorporate the comments in Armenian into the broader discourse?  Or will the Armenia-based ethnographer codify the comments alone?

Actually we encourage everyone to stick to English…

The static content/instructions are translated…however the conversation ought to be in English predominantly. The rule being Euro English and respect: Native English speakers are reminded they are the minority in Edgeyders, not the norm.

… and we might need some help for ethnographers

As Nadia said. But in the end, people will write in whatever language they want: if we have material in Armenian only we will need to find someone to code it using the common ontology of codes. We have a little money set aside for doing that.

Thanks!

Nadia, Alberto, Pehr, thanks for your feedback.

One additional question: during our weekly call I mentioned issuing a press release… pros - lots of people engaging with STF; cons - may make it mainstream and intimidate people at the edge.  I do not mind whether we issue a press realease or not.  What do you think?

I wouldn’t say no

It can’t hurt, once they engage, people tend to self-select, some stay some don’t… your call?

Guys why don’t we do a Twitterstorm?

It’s basically a press conference…on twitter :slight_smile: It’s a lot of fun  for everyone involved, even though it requires a little preparation. If you are upp for it, we will put together a nice…step by step guide for how we do it. Let me know!

Twitter is quite small in Armenia… but happy to give it a try.

Neither, but go ahead :slight_smile:
@george, unless Armenia is very different from anywhere else I have worked, media are unlikely to have traction on this sort of dynamics. That goes both ways: they don’t bring new users and content (and why should they? media cultivate passive audiences of consumers, so that’s what they tend to get), but neither do they don’t scare anyone off (and why should they? active people do their thing regardless of what media say – and many have dropped media consumption altogether. See Nassim Taleb’s observation that “media is 99% noise”, Duncan Watts’s mantra that “science is the only news”, the widespread idea that “media is to the brain what sugar is to the body” etc.).

I would go ahead with your press release, on the off chance that it might bring along some interesting user; and also as a way to signal your office’s style of work. As Noemi says, can’t hurt. But I would not expect anything dramatic to come out of it.

ok, thanks, i’ll get in touch with comms in the morning.

let’s talk tomorrow morning

Hey @george, I am working on some texts (that could be used for the press release), in parallel to bringing new people into the platform. I will share what I manage to finish soon.

Thanks Vahagn.  I tried to email you through the edgeryders messaging system re. sociocracy this coming friday (we forgot to exchange contact details :).