Guiding principles for conflict management

Hello dear @reef-full @reef-associate

Context

Next weekend we will have a 2-day Reef Retreat!

On Sunday afternoon team conflict management will host a session on the guiding principles and interpersonal agreements we have been working on.

In this post we will share what we, with Team Conflict Management, consider key agreements we should make within the Reef to help us navigate conflicts.

The idea is that you can think about them before coming to the retreat: What comes up for you when you read these: are you happy to agree to them, are they within your margin of tolerance, are they understandable, are some key concepts missing,..

During the retreat we will ask you to visually indicate which ones you agree with, which one need more discussion, and what is missing. We will focus the conversation on the elements that require change.

The purpose is to have guiding agreements that all Reeflings will consent to as a framework to support us in dealing with conflict.

Guiding principles and interpersonal agreements

1. Connection:
I will make an effort to build stable relationships with the people I live with, and when I feel out of harmony with someone, I will look for an opportunity to reconnect.

2. Goodwill
I will try to start from the assumption that others mean well, even when their words or actions land differently for me.

3. Plurality
I will remember that we can share the same goal while having very different ideas about how to get there.

4. Engagement
I am willing to stay engaged and work through personal conflicts, rather than letting them quietly grow or drive us apart.

5. Awareness
Before reacting, I will take the necessary time to notice what is happening — in myself, in others, and in the situation.

6. Non-blame
I will try to talk about what happened and how it affected me without turning it into blame, shame, or a verdict on the other person.

7. Curiosity
When something doesn’t make sense to me, I will try curiosity before jumping to conclusions. I can ask, “Can you help me understand?”

8. Playfulness
I will make room for humor, play, joy, and a good laugh. We are building a home together, not running a monastery.

9. Growth
I am willing to reflect on conflicts, learn from mistakes, and adapt my behavior when needed.

Final note
We are looking forward to receiving your feedback and aligning on how to manage conflicts in the coming week(s)

With love
Team Conflict Management

14 Likes

Looks like great work, well done!

Hello Gaultier, I was wondering if those of us who cannot be present next Sunday could also contribute and in which format?

1 Like

Hey Richard!

Good question :slight_smile:

I imagine we would take the feedback from the retreat to finalize the agreements and bring them to a plenary for consent.

If you can’t be there for the in-person discussion during the weekend you can also leave your thoughts in this thread and we will take it into consideration when working on the final proposal.

Potentially we will discuss feedback in this thread during the session on Sunday and I think we will write a debrief in this thread after the retreat.

Does that support?

2 Likes

Yes works, if I won‘t be able join to join, I‘ll leave my thoughts here in this thread.

1 Like

As I’m unfortunately not able to join the workshop I leave my personal thoughts here:

I believe that some level of alienation within a group is normal, and it is not something that necessarily needs to be constantly addressed or mediated.

I would even say that alienation is something we are confronted with continuously in many different areas of our lives, whether at work, within our families, or in a cohousing context. While mediation and Nonviolent Communication (NVC) can certainly be helpful, they also have their limits, and I think we have had our share of both at the Reef.

This is where I believe that politeness and a certain degree of mutual indifference (ignorance!) can be useful. When I realise that I have made an effort but simply do not connect well with a particular person, I feel it is best to respectfully create some space. I may greet them, ask how they are doing, and then go my own way.

I think NVC can provide valuable guidance on the politeness aspect by teaching us how to maintain a civil and inclusive culture. However, continuous engagement and connection are not necessarily what I would strive for. Instead, I would choose to disengage to some extent and allow each person the freedom to pursue their own path.

I am obviously not an anthropologist, yet I would argue that politeness and a certain degree of respectful distance are strategies that have helped humankind maintain social harmony and coexist peacefully. I also think we have seen these dynamics at play at the Reef and interpret it as a good sign.

12 Likes

I didn’t participate in the discussion during the Retreat, if I were there, I would have shared the same feeling.

5 Likes

@AlinT made the same point. He proposed that if a tension is not affecting the group, it’s ok to leave it be.

5 Likes

Hello @reef-conflict,

Unfortunately I couldn’t be there. This would have been my feedback:

  • Overall it looks great and I look forward to signing up for it.
  • I am missing maybe two elements:
    • Conflict resolution & talking to people (instead of about them). This is the text from Heartwood that I find inspiring:
      “I agree to take problems and complaints to the person(s) with whom I can resolve them, at the earliest opportunity. I agree not to criticize or complain to someone who cannot do something about my complaint, and I will redirect others to do the same. I will not say behind someone’s back what I am not willing to say to their face.”

    • Feedback & impact. Here I don’t have a ready made formulation. It would need to say something like “I will not lash out at other people” and “I will be mindful about the impact of my words and behaviour on others, and I accept to be held accountable when something I did or said had an unintended impact on somebody else”. This would subscribe to the philosophy of the Piedmont Peace Project (see post about power-under) who list unacceptable behaviours in their guidelines as means to create more emotional safety. Another example is RHD Bill of Rights which can be found online.

3 Likes

Hello @reef-full @reef-associate

During the Reef Retreat team Conflict management presented the guiding principles and interpersonal agreements we propose.

Thanks to the great participation of many Reeflings we got some very useful feedback that we will use to rework the principles and agreements. :heart:

This post is a way to share this feedback with all Reeflings. If anyone who couldn’t attend would like to add something you can do it in this thread!

I have sorted the feedback from most to least contested principle. This is also the order in which we discussed them during the Retreat.

Missing principle: Group impact

Quite a few people gave feedback that tension and conflict is a normal part of life. Not everything needs to be resolved. The question is rather does this tension or conflict impact our group substantially or endanger our project. We think a principle and agreement should be added to include this idea.

Principle 4: engagement

The agreement could be too much for a person with anxiety or trauma related to conflicts. Some people get blocked or can’t engage.

At the same time not every conflict needs to be engaged with, if it doesn’t affect the group it’s okay to let it exist.

What is important is to not hide the conflict (sweep it under the rug) while adapting to individual needs.

Principle 1: connection

Not everyone is interested in deep connections with everyone. It is again important to focus on the impact on the group.

The word ‘harmony’ in the agreement has new age connotations and could be replaced by something else. Benevolent neutrality was suggested.

The use of the word harmony could lead to conflict avoidance as a way to keep harmony rather than expressing and working through serious tensions.

Principle 5: awareness

The agreement and principle seems to already be contained in growth and curiosity as well.

Taking ‘the necessary time’ could be used as an excuse to avoid dealing with the conflict or tension in a serious way.

Principle 8: Playfulness

The expression ‘we are not running a monastery’ is poorly chosen as monasteries can be quite fun and joyful. After some discussion about whether we should replace it by ‘we are not running a business’ the suggestion is to drop the expression altogether.

Not everybody want to be funny or joyful all the time.

The purpose of the agreement is more to remind ourselves to be lighthearted and not take ourselves too seriously as a way to de-dramatize the situation.

Principle 6: Non-Blame

Change the name of the principle. As humans we will always blame so there is no point is saying we won’t.

Principle 9: Growth

Maybe change the principle to ‘integrity’ to maintain a sense of objectivity, and focus on truth. Rather than ‘how it lands of me’ or ‘how I feel about it’.

Experiencing growth is very personal and subjective. It is not something we require from people.

New principle: forgiveness

A new principle was suggested with the agreement:

Face it, resolve it, move on, done.

It seems to be encapsulated in other agreements but is retained at least for this debrief because I like the wording a lot.


Thanks again for your great input and to the people who already responded in this thread!! We will get back to you with an updated version very soon!!

                               Team Conflict Management
10 Likes

Thanks a lot for the work Gaultier :folded_hands:

My understanding of the discussions was that the idea is also to suggest that forgiveness is not necessarily a “mandatory” goal — since one cannot force someone to forgive — but rather that the objective, after discussing and addressing a conflict, is to move on (whether by resolving the conflict, lessening it, or accepting that some tension will remain) without constantly circling back to the original issue.

2 Likes

I think I see where this is coming from, and at the same time I would find it a pity if we throw out the baby with the bathwater. It’s not because we are socialised to blame that we must give in to it. I think an important function of the guidelines is providing more emotional safety. A collective commitment to not throw undigested blame at anybody would be an important element to me.

1 Like

Just to be clear, we will still keep the principle “I will try to talk about what happened and how it affected me without turning it into blame, shame, or a verdict on the other person”
We need to recognise the ‘blaming’ thoughts in our head (as they will inevitably come up during a conflict) and translate these to more neutral ways of communication in which we focus on how the conflict affects ourselves rather than on blaming the other. Curiosity is also connected.

Also, the title is just a bit off (“non” blame sounds weird).

3 Likes