Consent or object to prolonging the mandate of the board of the Sosim

Hi @reef-full @Jolien @BramV

Background

In the GA of 23/08/2025 the mandate of the board of the Sosim, consisting of Lee, Alberto, Richard, Sophie and Els, was prolonged to October 2026.

Current situation

Some of the current full members indicated an interest in possibly wanting to join the board of the Sosim by starting the leadership track.
@Wenwei @GaultierDWM started the track on October 10th and already joined the board for a first board meeting, while @AlinT started the track on October 15th.
A leadership track takes 6 weeks more or less.(more info on the leadership track)

Sophie is currently on a time out and Richard will also be out at a certain point in the coming year.

Proposal

The proposal would be to prolonge the current mandate of the board members till the GA of January 2027 at the very latest, in order to let the reeflings who have started up the leadership track finish this track. This will allow them to give it a full ‘yes’ or ‘no’ to be on the board if they would be selected.

Deadline

For the FM only: :heart: this message if you consent, otherwise share your concerns/objections by replying to this post by Thursday 22 October 19:00.

18 Likes

Irrelevant for this proposal, which I support, but :

I like what was said in the last plenary, that “heart”-ing a message means “READ”, not “I agree.”
I would love to consent to a proposal like this through a simple binary poll, “Okay for now, safe enough to try” or “Objection”.

5 Likes

Agreed

1 Like

With respect, but the online consent procedure is clearly described in our Governance Document, section 5.2.1.3.

1 Like

Yes, that’s true, but it raises an issue regarding the discussion we had during the last plenary session about using the “heart” icon as a “marker to indicate that a post has been read.”

Ideally, we should have two different reaction options on ER: a heart, and another icon to signify “read.”

In the meantime, a good compromise would be to establish that the “heart” reaction signifies “read”—EXCEPT for posts that explicitely ask for a consent; in those cases, the heart signifies “consent,” as stated in our current Governance Document.

1 Like

I think we are mixing up two things.

  1. The lack of being able to make the difference between ‘i have read this message’ and ‘i like your message’, creating unclarity/confusion what the ‘hearter’ means by his action. That is how I understood the need, brought up in the last PM. This - for me - goes for all er posts not requiring online consent.

  2. Online consent where it is clearly indicated in our governance document and where the ‘legend’ in the post clearly indicates what ‘hearting’ means. I don’t see the confusion or unclairty for this post. For me, the online consent doesn’t need any change as the heart clearly means ‘i consent’, not ‘i read’, nor ‘i like’. If you want to object, you will need to explain your objection anyway, just indicating that you object won’t do.

2 Likes

Yes, I agree with you for the point 2 :slight_smile:

And for point 1, it would be great if we could have a function on ER with two types of reactions to a post. If not, we will just need to remember that on a classic post (not one requireing an online consent as in point 2), heart = read.

1 Like

My understanding was that @reef-it would be looking into this. Is that a correct understanding?

1 Like

This is not a Reef choice, but an Edgeryders choice. I will float it past Matthias, but will not insist on him bending around our request. We can just agree “heart means reading” among us.

3 Likes

I would like to take a step back here and look at this issue from a few core principles:

1. The use of the heart function

Referring back to the full post About the use of the heart function, I think it’s important that we keep in mind that the reasoning behind it is to meet a need for connection and appreciation. As with everything though it is a request and not a demand - nobody is mandating you to heart a post if you don’t feel like it.

That does leave some ambiguity, which may feel uncomfortable to some I imagine. Therefore, if hearting a post doesn’t feel right to you, I warmly recommend you to stay close to yourself and not do it. On the other end of the spectrum: I see a few people hearting each and every post they have read. To me personally this does not contribute to connection, and at the same time I also want to support everybody to heart the way it feels right to them, so please don’t hesitate to continue hearting away :smiley:.

2. Doer decides

Our governance document is very clear on the fact that people taking on work can do that the way they see fit, provided they respect the governance and working methods. In the case of this online consent, these conditions were fully met. If somebody else would be doing an online consent post, they are of course fully free to use a poll or whatever brings them joy.

If somebody sees a risk to the current approach of just using the heart function, they can always come forward and clearly describe the harm we would be bringing upon our group and make a proposal on how to improve the current approach. If it would just be a matter of personal preference though, my recommendation would be to remind yourself that it just needs to be in your range of tolerance, and to preserve our commitment to self-management and autonomy by letting doers decide.

1 Like