AMA on COVID-data planning - WIP

Proposed text for the event introduction by @Alberto:

"For over ten years, we have been hearing that data have become a key resource, “the new oil”. In combination with the Internet as a general delivery infrastructure and new data processing techniques, like machine learning, they power new services. Some of these are potentially benign (recommendation algorithms), others decidedly creepy (facial recognition); both types are changing our societies. Estimates circulated in 2019 put at over 1 trillion Euro the projected value of the data economy in the EU. Civic-minded technologists have argued that many important datasets, especially those produced by the public sector or funded by taxpayers, should become public goods, accessible to all without restriction. Open, machine-readable public information would not only benefit the economy, but improve transparency and strengthen democracy. Policy makers, at least in Europe, heard the call; the EU Public Sector Information Directive dates back to 2003, and got an overhaul as the Open Data Directive in 2019.

It looks like all stakeholders agree on the strategic importance of open data as a common societal resource. And yet, after all this time, when the COVID-19 crisis erupted in early 2020, the open data pipelines burst at the seams. In many countries, it has been surprisingly difficult for researchers, journalists and citizens to access even basic data on how the pandemic played out. And this happens at a time when authorities are making controversial decisions to limit the freedoms of citizens – decisions that, naturally, citizens would like to better understand. Why, after all this time and lofty rhetoric, are we so bad at basic open data? Is it a capacity problem, with public servants working out of Excel sheets rather than with robust data delivery pipelines? Is it the temptation of using strategically the information on COVID-19, that struggling politicians simply cannot resist? Or what else?"

Personal Info needs updating:

We are Giorgia Lodi and Andrea Borruso, and we care about the issue. Andrea is a co-founder of Italian civic tech NGO OnData. OnData launched a petition to prime minister Giuseppe Conte to release all epidemiological data as open data, and to open the algorithms that convert those data to risk indicators (like Rt) that the authorities base their policy decisions on. To date, the petition has 46,000 signatories, including 162 organizations. Meanwhile, Giorgia, formerly with the Italian government agency for the digital society, is involved in an epic struggle for the openness of the data in Italy.

We are onboarding Giorgia and Andrea to the platform via this thread to give some feedback on the text and add their information and pictures.

The thread is a wiki, so you can edit it directly or just reply to it with your feedback.

Andrea and Giorgia, could you, either way, please also upload a profile picture of yourself which we could use for flyers?

Looking forward to this!

1 Like

@MariaEuler post edited. Please note the spelling: Giorgia, not Georgia.

Could you maybe set up Giorgia and Andrea with accounts?

1 Like

Will do when they have time later this week.

Hi guys! Here I am :slight_smile: About the photo, I am trying to get familiar with the platform. Anyway, I will :slight_smile:


@giorgia.lodi great to have you here!

to upload a picture, just press the little icon I marked yellow here when making a post, select from your computer and press "upload: :slight_smile:


1 Like

Maria, done! :slight_smile:

1 Like

Could I get some feedback on how to call this event?

The WIP title is “Covid Data AMA” Should I go with this or do you want another title?


Covid data AMA

1 Like

you can find the draft for the event here: AMA - Data Openness and Covid

And people can commit questions and sign up for a reminder here: Edgeryders Forms

What do you think about changing the title to:

“AMA - Data Openness in times of Covid”

too cheesy?

@giorgia.lodi, welcome, and thanks for making the effort! :slight_smile:

1 Like







Covid data AMA

I move some posts form the live chat post to this thread to clear up the space for the livechat a bit more :slight_smile:

For everybody: in Italy we decided to take decisions based on data. That’s very important btw. The idea is that Italian regions are colored according to three main colors yellow: you can do something but other things not (e.g., you cannot go to the restaurants during the evening); orange (there are some restrictions. but still there is some freedom of movement); red (you essential are quite stuck at home with some exceptions). Well, for a week one Italian region was in red area because based on some data that the central government collects, the resulting color was red. They complained a lot since they claimed it was not true. Nobody, especially citizen couldn’t verify that. Where is the truth? Opening up data allows us to better control these cases and probably avoid unnecessary controversies :slight_smile: