Here they are As you see, these are just notes, so don’t be surprised about weird and messy content. Mostly these are plans for an electronics project. But you might find the survey of existing technology and open source projects relevant, esp. the VE.direct protocol and emonPi.
(The file will open directly in the browser, replacing the site navigation. Click on + to unfold the list. It’s exported from FreeMind.)
Yes if it’s about people feeding back into the grid. Not if it’s about demand planning and all locally produced electricity is consumed locally or via direct connections to neighboring houses. The grid would still be a failover solution and backup, but there would be no need for the expensive certification process of grid-tried inverters. For more details about this concept, see:
@eb4890 thank you very much for describing your project! Sounds amazing.
Feel free to invite those conversation partners of you to our platform as well! What are the next steps you are planning? Is there anything specific you feel you would need to get off the ground? If yes, please share your calls for ideas, collaborators or meetings here with and images so we can share them further and help each other to grow this bigger :).
I’m going to create a website explaining the concept more to use in comms. I’ve not had much time recently to do anything on this, next week is my next bit of free time.
This is a tall order indeed, and you seem like you’ve got the background and experience to take a credible stab at it. I don’t know the first thing about energy grids but I do know about the power of collaboration in large scale endeavors; would you indulge me for a sec and help me and others here understand which the most relevant communities are that you’d need to work with in order to make progress on this?
For example, if you’d like to tackle a disease of some kind, you’d likely want some university medical centers involved as well as medical folks with experience in the relevant locales, and maybe some NGOs on the ground with the means to reach out onsite.
What would be the equivalents for you, which are the kinds of complementary skills or networks you’d need to have the best chance of making this work, or where do you see existing work that could be leveraged to get there?
There are multiple different scenarios it could be deployed in and depending upon which scenario you are going for depends upon who you talk to.
On earth, micro-grid scenarios with equipment from multiple different people: You would want to talk to NGOs/ and other orgs that set up away from current infrastructure and need something to manage demand/flow.
Grid attached solar/battery/e-vehicle setups: You would need to talk to grid management companies
(e.g. National Grid PLC in the uk) and the governmental regulators.
In space, micro-grid scenarios with equipment from multiple different people: ESA, NASA, blue origin, CNSA.
You would need to do scenario two to achieve significant CO2 reductions, but it might best be approached from trying to achieve scenario one or three first.
Currently I don’t know which scenario is the easiest to approach, so I have to think about all three. I’m a little burned out from my previous project and current job stress, so it might well take me a while build networks or skills.
I’m working slowly on some stories to try and make concrete what my current thoughts are, to spark future conversations.
@pbihr Thank you very much for your thoughtful questions and interest in learning about and in pushing the interesting project further!
@eb4890 Thank you for the mapping out of those initial scenarios. We hope you can find all the time and energy you need and that this community can help you with that.
I find your approach with the stories extremely interesting! I think it would be great if you would also post them here in the stories category with a small introduction and maybe an image if you have one. Those could be great to connect to more people and draw interest and collaborator into the project, and we would be happy to share those as well
I think this is really pretty on point, but surely there must be some project trying to acchieve this already out there? I dont know of any myself though, but it makes sense, so if not, its over due to start working on it…
Hi Julia. There are lots of people building different bits that solve some of these problems.
Energy companies have some protocols for communicating with smart meters, but it is not standardised so your smart meter might lose smart functionality when switching supplier.
Another example of solving part of the problem is the sion car can choose to share it’s energy but mainly through the centralised app. This means you are reliant on an internet connection in order to be able to share your car and have the other potential problems inherent in relying on a centralised service (such as it going away or becoming less reliable). You also may want to share your energy on a mutual credit basis rather than selling it, so it may not suit you. I don’t know of anyone who is trying to solve it in a decentralised way. These ways are hard to monetise and so hard to build a company around. But there may be something I don’t know about.
This was a great conversation to read and code. I was however wondering how people feel about the privacy concerns inherent to smart-meters. Some cities (like Amsterdam) have made them mandatory.
A friend of mine, permanently DDoS his meter to prevent the energy company from getting in-vivo updates on his energy use. Because does not see why this is necessary given the fact that the by-hand measuring system also works.
There is also the question of the accuracy of such smart meters:
Where I live in northern California the controversy about smart meters was not so much privacy but the radiation waves it puts out when it ‘phones home’ which they do on and off all day.
Many here are also freaked out about wifi and cell towers, to the point that some parents a few years ago made the local high school remove their school-wide wifi system. But then, where I live many people are convinced that airplanes leave “chem trails” in their path that are meant to make us all dumber or turn us into sheep or something along those lines.
Interesting (yet not surprising) to see how the same technologies raise different societal question based on the various broader political discussions they’re embedded in (i.e. efficiency through smart meters in the netherlands, conspiracy + health in the us, and environmental concerns in many countries).
Academics tend to talk about this phenomenon in terms of “domestication theory” which holds that people integrate (and subvert) technologies into their lives on their terms, rather than just wholesale taking or using them as given by their designers.
Would love to read more on how the domestication of technologies (like wifi or 5G) leads to different societal concerns and hence, to different civil society and regulatory responses.
Anyways, did not mean to hog this thread with unrelated musings. So back to the electricity grid
The county I live in - Mendocino in California - has the highest per capita number of off-grid houses in the country. But I don’t think there are microgrids here.
My idea for Phloem is that the data would be owned and controlled by the user ideally. My idea for phloem is partially based on secure scuttle butt, where your various computers could follow your smart meter and store the data long term.
It gets more complicated when you try and figure out how much data to send to the energy companies. In a normal grid tied situation they need pretty accurate data, so they can both bill and predict energy demands.
In a situation where you have your own battery they only need to know your demand for grid energy (and predicted demand), not your entire energy usage. This could hide some demand and preserve privacy a bit more, so they can’t necessarily tell when you are home based on your energy usage, etc.
It both situations (and a long time from now, barring government regulation), you could imagine smart meters only sending their daily usage on a per house basis and the energy companies getting combined usage data from substations.
This would still allow power companies to predict demand accurately.
Just to let people know why I am not working on this at the moment, I haven’t had much engagement from the protocol design people. So it seems unlikely to help with CO2 emissions in the next 10-20 years, which was my hope. It would need significant investment and interest from lots of different parties and lack of engagement from the people I expected to be most interested was pretty discouraging overall.
So I am currently looking at putting my technical skills behind things that will either definitely help a small amount in a short time frame, or potentially help a lot in the long time frame.
I didn’t know you were thinking in this direction but it’s exciting to hear! How far along are you in the project and can one read more about it somewhere?
Also, where abouts are you physically now? Edgeryders is hosting a festival all around and the one in Malmö will be gathering some people from Scuttlebutt as well as having a deep green theme.
Maybe one of the teams of COAT or you @eb4890 wanna join the hackathon? Seems like a great opportunity to refine the concept, find collaborators an connect with the community.
As you see, these are just notes, so don’t be surprised about weird and messy content. Mostly these are plans for an electronics project. But you might find the survey of existing technology and open source projects relevant, esp. the VE.direct protocol and emonPi.
